Five of the Coolest Restaurants in Sheffield
02 Jun 2025
The Steel City – it’s not just about indie music and the best accent in the UK (sorry, Manchester). Sheffield’s food scene is hotter than a freshly forged blade, and it’s got a clutch of restaurants that are cooler than a snowman’s sunglasses.
Whether you’re after Nordic-Japanese fine dining in a converted paper mill or Sardinian small plates that’ll make you want to pack your bags for Cagliari, we’ve got you covered. So, pull up a chair, loosen that belt, and get ready for five of the coolest restaurants in Sheffield right now.
1. JÖRO at Oughtibridge Mill
You know a restaurant’s got serious vibes when it moves house and levels up in the process. JÖRO has packed its bags from Kelham Island and moved to a 19th-century paper mill in Oughtibridge – talk about a glow-up. Chef Luke French is still running the show, serving up his fancy-pants Nordic-Japanese tasting menus (think grilled scallops, teriyaki quail, and things you can’t pronounce but will love anyway). It’s fine dining, but not in a stiff way – expect big flavours, creative plating, and a room full of people who definitely know what a yuzu kosho is. Oh, and did we mention the boutique rooms and deli? Yeah, it’s that kind of place.
2. Domo
Domo isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a whole vibe. Tucked away in Kelham Island, it’s a Sardinian family affair serving up sunshine on a plate. The menu is a love letter to the owners’ hometown of Castelsardo – we’re talking fresh pasta, seafood straight off the boat, and a tiramisù that’s basically an edible hug. The team’s so friendly you’ll leave feeling like part of the family, even if you only came in for a quick lunch. Pro tip: don’t skip the cocktails, and definitely grab a jar of Sardinian honey from the deli on your way out. You’ll thank us later.
3. Cambridge Street Collective
Who needs a passport when you’ve got Cambridge Street Collective? This food hall is massive – it’s officially the largest purpose-built one in Europe – and it’s the kind of place where your indecisive friend will spontaneously combust from too much choice. From Thai street food to Mexican tacos, West African stews to wood-fired pizza, it’s a global smorgasbord where you can eat your way across continents without leaving Sheffield city centre. It’s loud, it’s fun, it’s a little chaotic – basically, it’s the perfect spot for your next big group hangout or that awkward first date where you can’t agree on what to eat. Sorted.
4. Six and a Half
Six and a Half might sound like the name of a dodgy indie band, but it’s actually a laid-back gem on Sharrow Vale Road. The vibe? Think small plates, big flavours, and a soundtrack that’s more “dinner party bangers” than “elevator muzak.” Chef Leslie Buddington (ex-Brocco on the Park) is all about wood-fired goodness: harissa venison, roasted leeks with smoked cheddar, and charred everything. It’s the kind of place where you’ll end up ordering one of everything, because let’s face it, sharing plates are just an excuse to try the whole menu without judgement. Costly, cool, and a bit of a local secret (until now).
5. La Bottega
La Bottega is Sheffield’s answer to a chic European wine bar, but with a proper Yorkshire welcome. It’s the kind of place where the wine list is longer than your arm, the plates are seasonal and ever-changing, and you’ll inevitably say, “let’s just get one more dish.” Expect small plates with a big punch – perfect for a relaxed date night or a catch-up with your mate who’s just got back from “finding themselves” in Italy. It’s cool but not in an intimidating way – you can wear your trainers and still feel fancy, which is the dream, really. Book now and enjoy one of the best restaurants in Sheffield.
And that’s a wrap!
So, there you have it – five of the coolest restaurants in Sheffield, each bringing their own special magic to the table. Whether you’re after a tasting menu that’ll make you feel like a proper grown-up or a casual spot where the wine flows and the vibes are immaculate, Sheffield’s got you covered. Now, go forth and feast – and don’t forget to save us a seat.
Discover more of Yorkshire’s finest dining experiences in our other FoodNoise guides and reviews—because life’s too short for mediocre meals.
5 of the Best Pubs for Father’s Day Lunch 2025
Pairings Wine Bar: A Civilised Sanctuary in the York Saturday Night Safari